Deck Builder

Deck Builder

The deck builder is where the collection management really starts to pay off. Because your cards are tracked, you always know exactly what you own versus what you need, which makes it a lot easier to build something that'll actually work at the table.

Creating a Deck

Go to the Decks page and click New Deck / Import. It walks you through five short steps, in order, every time:

1

Mode. Catalog, Builder or Theorycraft, each with what it does and when to use it (more below). If you're not sure, there's a Not sure? Answer two questions link that picks for you.

2

Starting cards. An empty deck, a precon, or a list you import from another site.

3

The basics. Name and format.

4

Collection counting. Whether your collection should count this deck at all.

5

Review. Exactly what creating the deck will do, before it does anything.

It's five steps instead of one form because picking the wrong mode is the one way a deck can quietly mess up your collection. The review screen is the safety net: if you're about to catalogue a precon and some of its cards are already in your collection in the same printing, it names them and offers Use Builder instead, because if those are the same physical cards, you'd otherwise end up with two of each.

Starting from a Precon

If you're building from a preconstructed deck (a Commander precon, a Challenger Deck, a Starter Commander Deck, that sort of thing), you don't have to add 100 cards by hand. Pick A precon at the starting-cards step and search by name or commander. It's offered on Catalog and Theorycraft, because you either have the box or you're building toward it. It isn't offered on Builder: a precon is something you buy, not something you assemble out of spare cards.

In Catalog every card in the precon becomes a new copy in your collection, and the review screen tells you how many before you commit. In Theorycraft every card starts as not owned, and anything you already have a spare of gets a Use from collection button. From there you tweak: swap a few cards, replace the commander, upgrade the manabase. Much faster than typing 100 cards to change nine of them.

Your Deck List

The Decks page shows all your decks as visual cards with their cover art, format badge, and build status. Drag a deck's cover art up or down to reframe how it's cropped, and it stays that way. Use the format filter in the sidebar to narrow it down, or search by name. You can also set any deck as your Active Deck, which makes it easy to add cards from the Search page with one click. Deleting a deck always asks what happened to it. Took it apart means you still have the cards, so they stay in your collection as spares. Traded or sold means they're gone, so they leave your collection too. Close that question without picking and nothing is deleted. Removing a single card asks the same thing (do you still have it?), including when you're only taking one copy off a stack. Proxies and cards you don't own yet just go, since there's nothing to ask about.

The Editor Layout

The deck gets the screen. Down the right is the Overview: how many cards you've got against what the format wants, what the deck is worth (split into real cards and proxies if you have any), the Export button, anything wrong with the deck, and its shape. On a narrower screen it folds down to a thin strip while you're adding cards, with the issue count still showing.

Adding cards. Hit Add cards, or press / from anywhere, and a panel opens on the left. It pushes the deck over rather than covering it, so you can still see what you're building and drag a result straight across. Close it and your search is still there next time you open it. For Commander decks, results are already narrowed to your commander's color identity, and the panel says so, because a missing card looks a lot like a broken search otherwise.

What the search covers depends on the deck's mode, so there's nothing to set. A Catalog deck searches every card, because you're recording what's physically in the deck. A Builder deck only searches cards you own, because that's all it'll take. Theorycraft is the one where you pick between All cards and Owned, since a deck you're building toward can be a mix of both.

Right under the search box there's a line that tells you what adding a card does on this particular deck: Adds to collection on Catalog, Owned cards only on Builder, Planning only on Theorycraft. It's there because that's the click that can change your inventory, and you shouldn't need to remember which mode you picked three weeks ago.

After you add a card, the message says what happened. On Catalog it's "Added. You now have 2 in your collection," with an Undo if you didn't mean it. On Builder it tells you when a card went in as a proxy. On Theorycraft it tells you when there's a spare sitting in your collection you could use.

Hovering a result shows Add and Proxy along the bottom of the card, plus Sideboard or Commander where they apply. Clicking the card itself opens its details rather than adding it, so you can read a card without accidentally putting it in the deck.

Viewing the deck. Three ways to look at it:

Stacks (the default): one column per card type, cards overlapping so only the title strip shows. Hover a card and the ones below slide down to show the whole thing. It's the only view where a hundred cards fit on one screen.

Grid: every card at full size, grouped by zone and type. Click a zone's heading to fold it away.

List: the text version, flowed into columns so a wide screen isn't mostly empty.

The size slider sets how big the cards are in Stacks and Grid. Your view and size are remembered. Hovering a card in the deck gives you minus and plus for the quantity and a button for its details, where the rest lives: foil, proxy, printing, sideboard, commander. There's no one-click "remove every copy" button, on purpose. Taking the last copy out still asks what happened to it.

Deck Health

The Overview carries the deck's shape: a mana curve with counts on each bar and the average mana value, colored pip counts, a breakdown of card types, and your land count. It recalculates the instant you add or remove a card, so you can watch the curve fill in as you build instead of finding out on the stats page afterward.

Suggestions

Suggestions live in the second tab of the Add cards panel. What they offer follows the deck's mode, for the same reason everything else does: the mode decides what a card you add actually is.

Catalog decks don't get suggestions at all. Adding a card there makes a new copy in your collection, so a suggestion would be the app suggesting you invent a card. The tab isn't there.

Builder decks only get cards you own. Ones with a spare copy come first, and if every copy of a card is already in another deck it's offered As proxy, so you can try it here without pulling it out of that deck.

Theorycraft decks get three cards you own and one to consider getting.

Commander decks get a switch at the top: EDHREC or Codex. EDHREC shows you what other people actually run with your commander, straight from EDHREC's numbers, with "52% of decks" on each card. Codex is our own read on your deck: its themes, the commander, and where it's structurally thin. They're good at different things. EDHREC knows what's popular and proven with that commander; Codex knows your deck, including the pet cards nobody else runs. Your pick is remembered in that browser. EDHREC suggestions don't count against anything, and if EDHREC has nothing for a commander (brand new ones, mostly) you get Codex picks and it says so. EDHREC's data is credited with a link back to them, because it's their work.

From each suggestion you can add it to the deck, push it to your wishlist, or dismiss it, and dismissed cards don't come back for that deck. Suggestions don't refetch while you edit; a dot on Refresh tells you the deck has changed since.

Suggestions are free, with no monthly usage limits for verified accounts. See What's Free.

Quick Swap

On a Builder or Theorycraft deck, open a card's details and pick Swap for another card. Search for what goes in (on a Builder deck it starts on cards you own), click it, and it's done in one step.

The card that comes out always stays in your collection as a spare. There's no "sold it" option here on purpose: a swap is a decision about the deck, not about your binder. The card going in follows the deck's rules, so on Builder it uses a spare, comes in as a proxy if every copy is already in another deck, and is refused if you don't own it at all. If the new card can't go in, the old one stays where it was. Catalog decks don't have Quick Swap, because adding a card there makes a new copy.

It asks before it does anything, and says what's about to happen to both cards. After the swap there's an Undo for about twenty seconds that puts the deck back exactly as it was, proxies and all. Undo won't work if you've changed the deck since, or if the card that came out has gone into another deck in the meantime. Swap them back by hand then.

Synergies & Combos

Synergies & Combos is in the deck's ⋯ menu: the cards in the deck that are best together, and the game-winning combos it has or is one card away from, each with a flow chart. On a Builder or Theorycraft deck you can add a missing piece from right there. The full story is in Pro Analysis & Combos.

Exporting a Deck

The Export button in the Overview copies your list to the clipboard in plain text, MTG Arena, or MTGO format.

Under that are the Have and Need lists. Have is every copy you own in the deck. Need is the Theorycraft shopping list: everything you haven't got yet. On Builder and Catalog decks with proxies there's a Proxied list too, for when you'd rather buy the real thing. Each one comes in three flavours: plain text (1 Sol Ring), TCGplayer, which pastes straight into their Mass Entry box with the set and collector number, and CSV with set, number and finish for a spreadsheet or another store.

Importing a Deck

Importing lives inside New Deck / Import: pick Import a list at the starting-cards step. Pick the source (Archidekt, Moxfield, Manabox, Dragon Shield, TappedOut, a plain text list, or auto-detect). It takes .csv, .txt, .dec and .dek.

A plain text list is the universal one, the 4 Lightning Bolt format that every site will hand you. Those work, including // Sideboard and // Commander headers, which file cards into the right zone as they come in. A list like that names no printing, so each card resolves to the most recent paper one, the same as a CSV without set codes, see CSV Import for the detail.

What each line becomes follows the mode, same as adding by hand. Catalog adds every line as a new copy in your collection. Builder uses your spares, makes a proxy where you own the card in another printing, and leaves out anything you don't own at all (and tells you which). Theorycraft brings the whole list in as not owned. Whichever you pick, the review screen reads the file first and tells you what's about to happen, so nothing is written until you've seen it.

Moving Cards Between Zones

You pick the zone when you add a card, not afterward. Anywhere you can add to a deck: search results, a card's details, or the builder's own search pane, there's a Sideboard option next to the usual add, and the card goes where you sent it. Formats that don't use a sideboard don't show the option, so you won't see it on a Commander deck.

The crown button promotes an eligible creature to the Command Zone. Attractions file themselves: add one anywhere and it lands in its own zone without being asked.

You can also move a card that's already in the deck. Hover any row in List View and there's a left-right arrows button that sends it to the other board, and the same thing is in the card's details panel. Mainboard to sideboard, sideboard back to mainboard, as often as you like. Nothing changes in your collection on the way: both boards are part of the deck, so the card stays in it.

One thing to know: it moves the whole entry. If you've got four of something in the mainboard and you only want one in the sideboard, the button moves all four. Splitting a stack across two boards still means stepping one down and adding it on the other side.

As for what the zones mean: Attractions sit beside the deck rather than in it, so they're counted and shown separately and never affect whether the deck reads as the right size. Sideboard cards don't count toward deck size either, but they do count toward the format's copy limit, so a second Sol Ring in a sideboard is still a second Sol Ring. There's no cap on how big a sideboard can be — the app has never enforced one, in any format.

Formats

FormatRequired SizeCopiesCommander
CommanderExactly 1001 (singleton)Yes
Standard60 minimum4No
Modern60 minimum4No
Pioneer60 minimum4No
Legacy60 minimum4No
CasualNo limitNo limitNo

Sixty is a floor in the constructed formats, not a target. A 61-card Modern deck is legal and the builder won't tell you otherwise. Commander is the one that's exact: a hundred cards, counting your commander.

Casual means casual. It isn't a lenient format, it's the absence of one, so the app doesn't check anything at all: no copy limit, no minimum or maximum size, no banned list, no sideboard cap. Forty copies of Lightning Bolt and a sixty-card sideboard is a Casual deck the builder will happily hand you without a word. If you want the app to tell you when something's wrong, pick the format you're actually building for.

Commander-Specific Features

Commander decks get a few extra features. The Command Zone is a dedicated slot that sits outside your 99. Partner commanders and "Choose a Background" commanders are automatically detected, so the system knows when two is correct. Card search is filtered by your commander's color identity, and if anything slips through that violates identity or copy limits, you'll see an amber warning banner explaining what's wrong.

Swapping Printings

If you want a different art or set version, open the card's details in the deck and choose Swap printing. You'll see up to 50 available printings. Click the one you want. If you already have that printing in the deck somewhere, the quantities merge automatically rather than creating a duplicate entry.

What happens to your collection follows the mode. On Catalog, your copy simply becomes the new printing. On Builder, the deck uses a spare of the new printing if you have one, and otherwise keeps it as a proxy, with your original copy going back to being a spare.

Proxies

You can proxy a card if you own at least one real copy of it, in any printing, and the proxy never uses up your real copy. Proxies show with an orange badge, they don't count toward whether a deck is "built," and the Stats page keeps their cost separate from real cards. Everything else about them, including making one real and what happens if you sell your last copy, is in Theorycraft & Proxies.

The Three Modes

Every deck is one of three things. The mode decides what a card you add to it actually *is*: a new copy in your collection, a copy you already have, or a card you don't own yet.

Underneath all three is one rule: a copy you own is either a spare or in exactly one deck. A spare is a copy beyond what your decks are using, counted per printing. Two decks can't both claim the same copy, which is what used to let one card show up twice.

Catalog is "I have this deck in hand, and it isn't logged yet." Every card you add becomes a new copy in your collection, even if you already have that printing (that makes a second one). It's what you want for a precon you just opened, a deck that's been sleeved for years, or a finished deck a friend gave you. It's not what you want for a deck built from cards you've already logged, because then everything would count twice. That's Builder's job.

Builder is "I'm building from cards I already have logged." A card uses a spare of that exact printing. If you don't have a spare of that printing but you own the card in another one, it goes in as a proxy, and your real copy stays a spare. If you don't own the card at all, it can't be added. Builder never creates a copy, so it's the safe one for brewing out of your binder, swapping in cards you own, or finding out whether a deck is buildable right now.

Theorycraft is "I'm planning a deck I don't fully own yet." Every card starts as not owned, and there are no proxies, because a card here is owned or it isn't. It's for pricing out a deck before you buy, working from a list you copied off EDHREC or a friend, or building a shopping list.

Owning a Theorycraft Card

On a Theorycraft card, Use from collection puts a spare you already have into the deck, and I got it adds a copy you just bought. The header keeps count (64 of 100), and Not owned after all leaves the copy in your collection as a spare. The rest of planning a deck you don't own yet is in Theorycraft & Proxies.

Deck Notes

The gear (Settings) on a deck's tile in your deck list opens Edit Deck, and Deck Notes is where you say what the deck is for: the power level you're aiming at, a budget, pet cards that stay no matter what, house rules. Pro Analysis reads them before anything else and won't suggest cards that go against them. If the deck is public, the notes show under its name on its public page, so keep anything private out of them.

Switching Modes

You can switch a deck's mode from its settings whenever you like.

Catalog and Builder switch back and forth freely, and nothing moves either way. The usual reason: you catalogued a deck you've had for years, ran the analysis, and now want to swap some cards in from your binder. Switch to Builder first, so the new cards come from your spares instead of being counted as new copies. If you open a finished, legal deck that's still in Catalog, it asks you about this before anything else.

Leaving Theorycraft needs every card to be owned, because a Builder or Catalog deck only holds cards you own. If some aren't, you get two choices: keep it as Theorycraft and keep collecting, or Mark all owned now, which uses your spares first and adds the rest as new copies.

Going to Theorycraft keeps the cards you own right where they are, and turns any proxies into "not owned," since Theorycraft doesn't have proxies.

Collection Counting (Tracked or Not)

Separate from mode, and it only answers one question: should your collection count this deck?

Tracked means the deck's cards show in your collection marked In *deck name*, and count in your totals.

Untracked means your collection ignores the deck completely: it's not in the lists, the totals, or the "own 2" badges in search. The cards are still yours, though. Pro Analysis, suggestions, Builder and Theorycraft all still know you own them. People use it to keep their collection page to loose cards only, with sleeved decks out of the way.

It never changes what you own, so you can flip it on any deck, in any mode, whenever you like. (That wasn't always true. It used to move cards around on some decks, which is exactly the kind of thing that let collections drift.)

If a Deck Asks You a Question

When we moved every deck over to this way of counting, a handful of decks were ambiguous, and rather than guess, the app asks. You'll see a box at the top of your Decks page (and on the deck itself) until you answer. Until then, those cards don't count anywhere in your collection.

"Are the cards in this deck yours?" This is an untracked Catalog deck, which your collection never counted, so it could be a deck you own or a list you made. Yes, add them to my collection makes every card a copy. Yes, some are already logged uses the copies already in your collection first and only adds the rest (the deck becomes a Builder deck). No, it's a list makes it a Theorycraft deck with nothing owned. If some of its cards are already in your collection in the same printing, it says how many, so you can pick the right one.

"Some cards have no record of where they came from." These are copies a Builder or Theorycraft deck was holding without a record of the collection copy they came from. They're mine adds them, I don't have them yet makes the deck Theorycraft, and Remove them from the deck takes them out.

Public and Private Decks

Decks are private by default. Open deck settings to make a deck public. Public decks get a globe icon on your deck list and are visible to anyone who visits your profile. Private decks stay hidden even if your overall deck list is public. Each deck can be toggled independently.

Deck Stats

Every deck has a Stats page with the full breakdown, see Deck Analysis.